picturebooksforolderreaders

 

Satchel Paige

Page history last edited by Christina Gendron 4 mos ago

Satchel Paige: Striking Out Jim Crow by James Sturm and Rich Tommaso, ill. NY: Hyperion Book, 2007 ISBN-10: 0786839007, Q5/5P.

            A powerful story about the infamous Satchel Paige who shaped baseball as we know it and entertained the world for generations. Drawings are done in black, white and tan with great depiction of motion and emotions of characters.

-Christina Gendron, 8/02/09

 

Satchel Paige Striking Out Jim Crow by James Sturm and Rich Tommaso. New York: Hyperion 2007.

ISBN: 9780786839001

A fictional African-American sharecropper, turns to Negro League baseball to support his family, narrates the story of Satchel Page, the baseball pitcher who helps to strike out Jim Crow laws.

Media: Pen and brush mechanical color added.

5Q/5P

Curriculum Connection

8th-11th Social Science Analysis Skills Historical Research, Evidence, and Point of View.

Theme  The effects of long term segregation of the psyche of African Americans in the United States. Although the book is about a growing pride within the black community about the prowess of Satchel Paige, the theme is deeper and reoccurring through out the book. When the teams go up against all white teams and win the group of the suppressed are ecstatic. In the end they defeat racism though perseverance and the changing of United States citizens attitudes to segregation. The growing pride at the end of the book is about a father having hope for his son and seeing a brighter future when the bonds of segregation and discrimination are lifted. How do small men get so large who made it so? (Sturm 2007).

  • use of simile through the text and/or through the illustrations.

Looks like an aspirin tablet streaking across the plate (Sturm 2007). Satchel Paige Striking Out Jim Crow by James Sturm.

 

D. Guhl Summer 2009

Satchel Paige Striking Out Jim Crow by James Sturm and Rich Tommaso. New York: Hyperion 2007.

ISBN: 9780786839001

A fictional African-American sharecropper, turns to Negro League baseball to support his family, narrates the story of Satchel Page, the baseball pitcher who helps to strike out Jim Crow laws.

Media: Pen and brush mechanical color added.

5Q/5P

Curriculum Connection

8th-11th Social Science Analysis Skills Historical Research, Evidence, and Point of View.

Theme  The effects of long term segregation of the psyche of African Americans in the United States. Although the book is about a growing pride within the black community about the prowess of Satchel Paige, the theme is deeper and reoccurring through out the book. When the teams go up against all white teams and win the group of the suppressed are ecstatic. In the end they defeat racism though perseverance and the changing of United States citizens attitudes to segregation. The growing pride at the end of the book is about a father having hope for his son and seeing a brighter future when the bonds of segregation and discrimination are lifted. How do small men get so large who made it so? (Sturm 2007).

  • use of simile through the text and/or through the illustrations.

Looks like an aspirin tablet streaking across the plate (Sturm 2007). Satchel Paige Striking Out Jim Crow by James Sturm.

 

D. Guhl Summer 2009

 

 Satchel Paige: striking out Jim Crow by James Sturm and Rich Tommaso. New York: Hyperion, 2007.

            ISBN: 9780786839018

            Annotation: This is the biography of Satchel Paige a great player in the Negro league of baseball. It show what a great character he was and how he helped get the African American players get notices by the white team owners and players as well as fans.

            Media: pen and ink

            Rating: 5Q/5P

            Subject: African-American History, Biography, Baseball. Grade 5-7

 

Lesson Plan

Goal

To teach students about Leroy “Satchel” Paige and the Negro league.

Objectives

 

 

-         To see the effects of segregation.

-         To learn about this episode in American history.

-         To be exposed to a non-fiction graphic novel.

-         To learn about the life of Satchel Paige

-         To practice baseball

Lesson

1.      Read the graphic novel. Discuss the story with students. Talk about the characters in the story.

2.      Play 2 baseball games, one as if it was the time of Satchel Paige and other as our present time

3.      Have students make a short research paper on Satchel Paige

Assessment

      -     During the discussion make sure every student participates and let them run the discussion to see if the students understood the story.

-         Set a minimum and some specifications for the research paper.

-         The baseball games will be to have fun but when they are playing the segregated game explain to them how this affected the players.

Armando Rivera 7-24-09

 

 

Satchel Paige: Striking Out Jim Crow by James Sturm and Rich Tommaso.  New York: Hyperion, 2007.

 

Summary: A former baseball player in a black league recalls his encounters with Satchel Paige, a real-life legendary player who did not let racism hold him back from achieving greatness.  

 

Rating: 5Q, 4P

 

ISBN: 0786839015

 

Medium: Pen/ink (black/white/green)

 

Curricular Connections: 

 

  • Excellent for English and History curriculum 
  • Themes: racism, Southern poverty, sharecropping, baseball, sports heroes, 1920s/1940s

 

Age Group: Middle/High School

 

Potential Obstacles: Use of racial epithets (though used effectively to convey  racism by white players toward black players)

 

 

E.K. 7/1/09 

 

 

 

APA Citation

 

 

Sturm, J and Tommaso, R. (2007). Satchel Paige: Striking out Jim Crow. New York: Hyperion.

 

 

ISBN

 

 

978-078683901-8

 

 

Rating

 

 

5Q/5P

 

 

Top 10

 

 

no

 

 

Media

 

 

Pen and brush

 

 

Grades/Subject

 

 

7-12; history, civics

 

 

Annotation

 

 

Satchel Paige was the highest paid baseball player, black or white. His story is transposed with that of a young man who remains in the south as a sharecropper.

 

 

Element Illustration

 

 

Rhythm

 

 

The juxtaposition of Emmett’s lolling Southern dialect with the sharp staccato rhythm of the newspaper reporting highlights Sturm’s control of rhythm in storytelling.

 

 

sk 4.27.08

 

 

Satchel Paige: Striking Out Jim Crow by James Sturm and Richard Tommaso, ill. New York: Jump at the Sun, 2007.  ISBN: 978-078683900-1.

 

 

Jim Crow, baseball, civil rights, no-hitters, and the excitement and showmanship of the Negro League are all uncovered in this fast-paced book featuring the life of legendary pitcher Satchel Paige.

 

 

Black, white, and pea-green graphics.

 

Curriculum Connections

English/Language Arts

Biographies/Autobiographies/Memoirs

Social Studies

Black History Month

Civil Rights

 

 

(DM 4.28.08)

 

 

Satchel Paige: Striking Out Jim Crow, by James Sturm & Rich Tommaso

Summary: The story of Satchel Paige, one of the most famous early black baseball players, is told through the eyes of another black ballplayer, whose career is cut short by an injury.

Analysis: This manages very well to be both fun to read and informative. It's told mostly in dialect, but not so colloquial that it's difficult to read for someone not fluent in it. It was somewhat confusing at first, because given the cover and inside blurbs, you expect the narrator or focus character to be Paige; but once the frame is established, it flows very nicely. There's an excellent introduction and explanation/bibliography at the back. The story covers life during Jim Crow laws quite thoroughly, and maintains a stream-of-consciousness feel that expects the reader to understand what's going on rather than being Educationally Expository (but then has good notes in case you're not familiar with something). The cover has a very This Is An Educational Book feel (it has an effectively "vintage" layout, but unfortunately got more of the "vintage schoolbook" feel than "vintage comic book", at least for me) that would probably detract many teens from picking it up on their own, but they'd likely be pleasantly surprised if assigned it for class.

Illustrations: White-olive-and-black ink drawings.

Rating: 5/4

Curricular Connections: This is perfect for a middle school unit on the civil rights movement. 

-- SLH

 

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.